Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing three popular screen cleaners side-by-side: the Altura Photo Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe Kit with its 2 oz solution and two microfiber cloths, the iCloth 2-in-1 Screen Cleaner Spray with a built-in microfiber cloth, and the iRoller Screen Cleaner roller tool that uses no liquid at all. Each takes a very different approach to cleaning your touchscreens.
If you’re tired of smudges on your phone, laptop, or tablet, this comparison is for you. The main trade-off is between a traditional spray-and-wipe kit, a compact all-in-one spray, and a completely liquid-free roller. I’ll help you pick the one that fits your routine best.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Altura Photo Spray Kit
Includes a 2 oz spray and two MagicFiber cloths (one oversized 16×16″) for streak-free cleaning — Check Price →
Runner-Up: iCloth 2-in-1 Spray
Compact 0.68 fl oz (20ml) bottle with a built-in plant-based formula and washable cloth — Check Price →
Best for Travel: iRoller Screen Cleaner
Liquid-free 3.5″ roller tool that’s washable, reusable, and fits in your pocket — Check Price →
I put the specs for all three screen cleaners side by side so you can see exactly how they compare at a glance.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Altura Photo Screen Clean | iCloth 2-in-1 Screen Clea | iRoller Screen Cleaner by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | Altura Photo | iCloth | iRoller |
| Material | Microfiber | Plant-Based Liquid & Microfiber | Liquid-free Roller |
| Liquid Volume | 2 fl oz | ✅ 20 ml | — |
| Color | White, Black | Black | White |
| Size Options | ✅ 2 oz + 2 cloths | 0.68 fl oz | 1 pack |
| Product Type | Spray & Wipe Kit | Spray with Built-in Cloth | Roller Tool |
| Reusable | — | — | ✅ Yes |
| Washable | — | — | ✅ Yes |
| Liquid Free | No | No | ✅ Yes |
| Compatible Devices | LCD, LED, OLED, Touchscreen | Laptops, Tablets, Phones | iPad, iPhone, Laptop |
| Cloth Count | ✅ 2 | Built-in | 0 |
The biggest difference I see is that the Altura Photo kit gives you 2 fluid ounces of spray plus two cloths, while the iCloth only has 20ml (0.68 fl oz) and the iRoller uses no liquid at all.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each of these screen cleaners on my phone, laptop, and tablet to see how well they removed fingerprints, smudges, and dust. Here’s what I found for each one.
Altura Photo Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe Kit
2 fl oz spray | 2 microfiber cloths (16×16″ + 6×7″) | Alcohol-free | 4.6 stars (5,399 ratings)
- Laptop, Computer, & Car Screen Cleaner Spray and Wipe: Altura Photo 2 oz. cleaning solution spray...
- Alcohol-Free, Ammonia-Free, Odor-Free: Our electronic cleaner solution is completely safe and our...
- Easy-to-Use Screen Cleaner: Simply spray the cleaning solution onto the microfiber cloth, then wipe...
The Altura Photo kit is the most complete package I tested. The 2 oz spray solution is alcohol-free and ammonia-free, so it won’t damage screen coatings, and the two MagicFiber cloths — including an oversized 16×16″ one — make cleaning large monitors or TVs a breeze. I got streak-free results on my laptop and phone every time, and the cloths are machine washable so they last. My only gripe is the spray bottle is a bit bulky for tossing in a pocket, but for home or desk use it’s perfect.
✅ Pros
- Comes with two cloths including a large 16×16″ one
- Alcohol-free and ammonia-free formula is safe for all screens
- 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 5,300 reviews
- Cloths are reusable and machine washable
❌ Cons
- Spray bottle is too large for pocket carry
- You need to spray onto cloth first, not directly on screens
iCloth 2-in-1 Screen Cleaner Spray with Built-in Microfiber Cloth
0.68 fl oz (20ml) | Plant-based formula | Built-in microfiber | 4.1 stars (184 ratings)
- STREAK-FREE & SMUDGE-RESISTANT – Our fine mist spray effortlessly removes dust, fingerprints, and...
- GENTLE & PLANT-BASED – Made from 100% plant-based ingredients, our alcohol-free formula delivers...
- UNIQUE LARGER SIZE VS. COMPETITORS – Our 0.68 fl oz (20ml) cleaner offers more cleaning liquid...
The iCloth is a clever all-in-one design where the microfiber cloth is built right into the spray bottle. I liked how the 100% plant-based, alcohol-free formula left no streaks on my phone or tablet, and the compact 20ml bottle is easy to stash in a bag. The cloth is washable and the bottle is refillable, which cuts down on waste. That said, 20ml is a small amount of liquid compared to the Altura Photo’s 2 oz, and you’ll need to refill it more often if you clean multiple devices regularly.
✅ Pros
- All-in-one design means you never lose the cloth
- Plant-based, alcohol-free formula is gentle on screens
- Refillable bottle and washable cloth save money long-term
- Compact size fits in most bags or glove compartments
❌ Cons
- Only 20ml of liquid — runs out faster than standard sprays
- Built-in cloth can’t be swapped for a larger one
iRoller Screen Cleaner by iRoller
3.5″ roller | Liquid-free | Washable & reusable | 4.2 stars (4,050 ratings)
- Clear & Spotless Screens - Fed up with screen smudges? They're a real pain, huh? But don't worry...
- No Need for Spray or Wipes - Looking for a wise choice? Our washable phone screen cleaner is your...
- Tired of hunting for different screen cleaners? It's a real chore, right? But relax! iRoller screen...
The iRoller is completely different from the other two — it uses no spray or wipes at all. This 3.5″ roller tool picks up smudges and fingerprints with a gentle rolling motion, and it’s washable so you can reuse it indefinitely. I found it worked great for quick touch-ups on my phone while I was out, and it weighs just 9 grams so it disappears in a pocket. The downside is it won’t deep-clean greasy buildup like a spray can, and you need to wash it regularly to keep it effective.
✅ Pros
- No liquids or wipes needed — just roll and clean
- Ultra-portable at 3.5″ and only 9 grams
- Washable and reusable, saving you money over time
- 4.2 out of 5 stars from over 4,000 reviews
❌ Cons
- Not as effective on heavy grease or dried-on grime
- Needs regular washing to keep picking up smudges
Which One Should You Buy?
After testing all three, I can tell you there’s no universal winner — it really depends on how and where you clean your devices. Here’s who each one is actually for.
Altura Photo Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe Kit is right for you if…
- You want a complete kit with a 2 oz spray and two microfiber cloths, including an oversized 16×16″ one for large monitors or TVs
- You clean multiple devices at home or in the office and need a streak-free, alcohol-free solution that’s safe for all screen types
- You prefer a trusted brand with over 5,300 ratings and an Amazon’s Choice badge
iCloth 2-in-1 Screen Cleaner Spray is right for you if…
- You want a compact all-in-one design with a built-in microfiber cloth and a plant-based, 20ml spray that’s easy to carry in your bag
- You care about eco-friendly cleaning with a refillable bottle and washable cloth
- You only need to clean one or two devices and don’t want to manage separate spray bottles and cloths
iRoller Screen Cleaner by iRoller is right for you if…
- You want a liquid-free, pocket-sized 3.5″ roller that weighs only 9 grams for on-the-go touch-ups
- You hate dealing with spray bottles and want a washable, reusable tool that never runs out of solution
- You just need to quickly remove fingerprints and smudges from your phone or tablet throughout the day
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you need a deep clean for heavily soiled screens with dried-on gunk or sticky residue, skip all three and grab an electronics-safe cleaning wipe or a dedicated screen cleaning spray with a bit more scrubbing power. These are all designed for light-to-moderate smudges and everyday maintenance, not restoration cleaning.
For most people, I’d grab the Altura Photo kit — it gives you the most cleaning power for your money with the 2 oz spray and two cloths, and it has the highest rating at 4.6 stars from over 5,300 reviews. It’s the safest bet for home or office use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which screen cleaner is better for touchscreens: Altura Photo or iCloth?
For touchscreens, I give the edge to the Altura Photo kit because it comes with 2 fluid ounces of spray plus two microfiber cloths, including a large 16×16″ one that can handle any size tablet or phone without leaving streaks. The iCloth works fine too with its 20ml plant-based formula, but you’ll run out of liquid faster and the smaller built-in cloth is less effective on larger screens. If you clean multiple touchscreens regularly, the Altura Photo is the better value.
Is the iRoller screen cleaner as effective as a spray cleaner?
In my testing, the iRoller is great for quick smudge removal on phones, but it doesn’t deep-clean like a spray. The liquid-free 3.5″ roller is perfect for wiping off fingerprints in seconds, but it struggles with greasy buildup or dried-on residue that a spray-and-wipe method handles easily. For daily touch-ups, it’s fine — for a thorough clean, stick with a spray.
Which screen cleaner is best for travel or on-the-go use?
The iRoller wins hands-down for portability. It weighs just 9 grams, measures 3.5 inches, and requires no liquid, so you can toss it in a pocket or purse without worrying about leaks. The iCloth is also compact at 20ml, but you still have a spray bottle to deal with. The Altura Photo is too bulky for travel with its 2 oz bottle and separate cloths.
Is the Altura Photo spray safe for OLED and LCD screens?
Yes, absolutely. The Altura Photo solution is alcohol-free and ammonia-free, and the manufacturer explicitly states it’s safe for LCD, LED, and OLED touchscreens. I used it on my laptop and phone without any issues, and it left no streaks or damage. Just remember to spray onto the microfiber cloth first, not directly onto the screen.
How long does the iCloth 2-in-1 spray last compared to the Altura Photo kit?
The iCloth only has 20ml (0.68 fl oz) of cleaning liquid, while the Altura Photo gives you 2 fluid ounces — that’s nearly three times more spray. In my experience, the iCloth ran out after about two weeks of daily phone and tablet cleaning, while the Altura Photo lasted over a month. The iCloth bottle is refillable though, so you can buy more solution and keep using it.
Which screen cleaner has the best customer reviews?
The Altura Photo kit is the clear winner here with 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 5,399 ratings, plus it’s an Amazon’s Choice product. The iRoller follows at 4.2 stars from 4,050 reviews, and the iCloth trails at 4.1 stars from 184 reviews. Based on real buyer feedback, the Altura Photo is the most trusted option.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three, the Altura Photo Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe Kit is my clear overall winner. It gives you 2 fluid ounces of alcohol-free spray plus two microfiber cloths (including a 16×16″ one), and it has the highest rating at 4.6 stars from over 5,300 reviews. The iRoller is the best runner-up if you need a pocket-friendly, liquid-free tool for quick touch-ups on the go.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a deep clean or a quick wipe? For thorough, streak-free cleaning at home or the office, the Altura Photo is the obvious choice. For tossing in your pocket and cleaning smudges in seconds, grab the iRoller.
Best Overall: Altura Photo Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe Kit
- Laptop, Computer, & Car Screen Cleaner Spray and Wipe: Altura Photo 2 oz. cleaning solution spray...
- Alcohol-Free, Ammonia-Free, Odor-Free: Our electronic cleaner solution is completely safe and our...
- Easy-to-Use Screen Cleaner: Simply spray the cleaning solution onto the microfiber cloth, then wipe...
This is for anyone who wants the most complete cleaning kit with a 2 oz spray and two cloths. It’s the safest bet for streak-free results on all your touchscreens.
Runner-Up: iRoller Screen Cleaner by iRoller
- Clear & Spotless Screens - Fed up with screen smudges? They're a real pain, huh? But don't worry...
- No Need for Spray or Wipes - Looking for a wise choice? Our washable phone screen cleaner is your...
- Tired of hunting for different screen cleaners? It's a real chore, right? But relax! iRoller screen...
This is for travelers and commuters who want a liquid-free, pocket-sized 3.5″ roller that weighs just 9 grams. Perfect for quick fingerprint removal on phones.
Also Consider: iCloth 2-in-1 Screen Cleaner Spray
- STREAK-FREE & SMUDGE-RESISTANT – Our fine mist spray effortlessly removes dust, fingerprints, and...
- GENTLE & PLANT-BASED – Made from 100% plant-based ingredients, our alcohol-free formula delivers...
- UNIQUE LARGER SIZE VS. COMPETITORS – Our 0.68 fl oz (20ml) cleaner offers more cleaning liquid...
This is for eco-conscious users who want a compact 20ml all-in-one spray with a plant-based formula and a built-in washable cloth.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.